Insight
Simon Case
When a downturn or a soft market arrives, one question turns up in almost every boardroom: should we keep spending on the brand and brand marketing?
Most companies decide they can’t afford to.
Most of them are wrong.
When revenue is threatened, the finance director looks for spending they can cut easily without anything obviously breaking.
And after reducing spending on doughnuts and staff pastries, brand marketing is usually next on the list.
The cost shows on this quarter’s P&L, while the value (assuming the finance director recognises any value in brand marketing!) is spread over years, where spreadsheets don’t see it. And because every finance director is reading the same numbers, they all make the same cut at the same time.
Which is good news for anyone who keeps their nerve.
For a century, studies of downturns have found the same pattern: companies that keep investing in their brand, and especially those that outspend their rivals while the rivals go quiet, usually come out with a bigger share of their market.
A hundred years of the same result
The earliest study we can find is Roland Vaile’s. He followed 200 companies through the American recession of 1923 and reported in the Harvard Business Review in 1927 that the firms which advertised most made the biggest sales gains.
In the late 1920s Kellogg and Post had packaged cereal more or less to themselves. Post did what most boards would do and cut its advertising. Kellogg’s directors were about to do the same when W.K. Kellogg came back from California and told them to carry on. In fact the company doubled its budget, much of it spent on radio (then a new medium) to launch a cereal called Rice Krispies. By 1933 its profits were up by almost 30%. It has led the category ever since.
The agency Meldrum & Fewsmith followed 143 firms from 1972 to 1977, through the 1974–75 recession. The ones that kept advertising finished well ahead on sales.
The study B2B leaders should know best came out of the 1981–82 recession. McGraw-Hill Research followed 600 business-to-business companies in 16 industries from 1980 to 1985. Everyone grew in the end. But firms that kept advertising through both recession years had grown sales to almost 340% of their starting level by year six. Firms that cut, in either year or both, managed a little over 200%.
Thomas Kamber looked at 822 companies after the 1990–91 recession. Those that held or raised their advertising grew sales by 7% in 1991, while the cutters stood still. By 1995 the gap was 25%.
The PIMS database, run by the Strategic Planning Institute, tracks market share itself. Its figures show that businesses which increased advertising in a recession gained 1.6 points of share in the first two years of recovery. Those that held spend gained 1.0 points, and those that cut gained 0.7. The bigger spenders weren’t much less profitable during the recession either, and their profits came back faster afterwards.
Peter Field studied 50 IPA effectiveness cases from the 2008–09 recession. Brands whose share of category advertising ran more than eight points above their market share (what Field calls excess share of voice) grew share by 4.5% a year. Brands with little or none grew by 1.0–1.4%. As Field put it, the brands that bounced back were the ones "that held their nerve". Analytic Partners, looking at a far bigger pool of data, found that two-thirds of the extra sales brands lost in that recession were down to cutting media budgets. Advertising still worked; there was just less of it.
When Gerard and Kethan Tellis reviewed more than 40 studies of advertising in recessions, they were blunt. Cutting hurts sales during the downturn and after it, without doing anything for profits. And whatever firms gain by spending, they tend to keep.
Why outspending works when times are hard
Brands that account for more of the advertising in their category than their share of sales tend to grow, and brands that account for less tend to shrink.
The catch is that in good times competitors tend to keep pace with each other, so nobody pulls ahead. The Strategic Planning Institute found that in boom years most businesses raised their advertising and almost none gained share. They had all done the same thing.
A recession ends this stalemate. When rivals go quiet, each dollar or pound a brand keeps spending buys more attention, while the media often gets cheaper. The Tellises make the same point: the best reason to advertise in a recession is that most firms stop, so there’s less noise for those left talking.
So the question is always relative. If you hold your budget while competitors halve theirs, you are outspending them. Field’s numbers say the same: the brands that pulled ahead were those whose voice most exceeded their share.
Field also had something to say about where the money should go. Looking at the 2008 cases, he argued that short-term sales activation makes much less sense when demand can’t be met or isn’t there. Most B2B buyers are out of market in a downturn. But they’ll buy later, and when they do, they’ll start with names they already know. A downturn is the cheapest time to become one of those names.
Advertising is only one way to be heard
The media of the 1920s, or even the 1980s, looks nothing like today’s. Vaile’s companies had newspapers and magazines. Kellogg had radio. A B2B buyer now forms a view of a company from search results, LinkedIn, the trade press, podcasts, events, analysts’ reports and what its senior people say in public, long before anyone from sales gets a meeting.
Most of the studies above measured advertising because advertising is easy to count. The principle underneath is broader: the more of a buyer’s mind a company holds, the more of their spending it tends to win. Paid media is one way to hold that ground. A distinctive point of view, a strong presence at the right events, coverage in the publications buyers trust and a leadership team worth listening to all do the same job, and in B2B they often do it better.
The downturn logic applies to all activities. When competitors cancel their conference stands, stop publishing and fall silent on LinkedIn, the company that keeps turning up with something useful to say gets noticed more, and often for less money. The research tracked advertising budgets, so applying it to PR or content is an inference; the studies don’t prove it. But the reason it works is the same.
Which makes this a question about brand investment as a whole, and a question for the board.
What this means for the board
Put simply, a downturn is an opportunity, and ambitious companies can come out bigger than they went in.
While competitors go quiet, attention gets cheaper, and buyers start drawing up the shortlists they’ll use when budgets reopen. Once share is won, it’s hard for anyone to take back.
Making the most of that opportunity is a board decision, and it deserves to be judged on the right numbers: market share, and what it would cost to win back any share handed to competitors this year. Set against those figures, this quarter’s savings usually look small.
So, yes, companies should trim waste. But the evidence shows that those who came through recessions strongly kept talking to their markets.
Plenty of companies will treat the next downturn as a storm to sit out. The ambitious ones will see a market that is suddenly up for grabs.
Sources
Tellis, G. and Tellis, K. (2009), Research on advertising in a recession: a critical review and synthesis, Journal of Advertising Research 49(3)
Vaile, R. (1927), Harvard Business Review, as summarised by Branding Strategy Insider: https://brandingstrategyinsider.com/recession-marketing-success-requires-boldness/
Surowiecki, J., The New Yorker, on Kellogg and Post, as summarised by MarketingProfs: https://www.marketingprofs.com/short-articles/1140/when-in-doubt-double-down
Kellogg Company history, Encyclopedia.com: https://www.encyclopedia.com/social-sciences-and-law/economics-business-and-labor/businesses-and-occupations/kellogg-company
McGraw-Hill, Meldrum & Fewsmith and Kamber studies, as reported from Tellis and Tellis by Practical Ecommerce: https://www.practicalecommerce.com/marketing-in-the-pandemic-creates-opportunities-afterward
Kamber, T. (2002), The brand manager’s dilemma, Journal of Brand Management 10(2)
PIMS share figures, Ebiquity/WARC: https://ebiquity.com/news-insights/press/in-the-press-maintaining-share-of-voice-is-key-in-recessions/
PIMS profitability findings, Hillier, T. (2009), Market Leader/WARC: https://www.warc.com/content/paywall/article/Successful_competitive_strategies_for_recession_and_recovery/9108
Field, P. (2020), Advertising in recession: long, short or dark?, LinkedIn B2B Institute; ESOV figures as charted by Ad Alliance: https://ad-alliance.de/download/3264086
Field, P., quoted by the IPA (2020): https://ipa.co.uk/news/peter-field-s-seven-lessons-for-advertising-during-a-recession/
Analytic Partners, as reported by Marketing Week: https://www.marketingweek.com/fight-dont-freeze-how-to-recession-proof-your-brand
